The Nationals Should Cash in on Trading Luis García Jr.

Entering the day with a respectable 51-50 record, the Washington Nationals are putting together a much better 2026 campaign than we thought they would. While the team is just eight games back in the National League East and surprisingly just one game out of the NL Wild Card race, they’re still at a bit of a crossroads ahead of this year’s trade deadline.

There’s no question that the Nationals have been better than expected, but the question is, do they have what it takes to leapfrog the teams above them in the standings? That’s where things get a bit murkier, and the answer feels like a “no.”

That in mind, it’d make sense for the team to open the door on trade conversations as we inch ever closer to the deadline. Somehow, we’re already just a few weeks away from all the madness commencing, and the Nationals would be wise to at least listen on the vast majority of their valuable players not named James Wood.

That includes Luis García Jr., who is enjoying a career year and has an additional year of control beyond the current one. The 26-year-old has already hit a career-high 20 home runs (14th in the NL) in his first 93 games this season, driving in 68 (5th in the NL) while sporting a 129 wRC+ (19th in the NL) and a strikeout percentage at its lowest since 2023.

It’s been a long and winding road for García to get to where he is today, and 2026 feels like the year the Nationals cash in on a trade chip they’ve stuck with for so long.

Read more

MLB

Luis García Jr. Has Found His Power at First Base

MLB

Is It Time To Worry About Dylan Crews?

Not All Prospect Development Is Linear

In recent years we’ve found multiple examples of former top prospects who take a while to find their footing at the game’s highest level, but when they do it can be oh so sweet. Jurickson Profar enjoyed a season-long breakout in 2024, over 10 years into his MLB career. This year’s Home Run Derby champion, Jordan Walker, is finally capitalizing on his own sky-high potential as well.

While he’s not having as loud of a breakout as Walker is, García own ascent is a long time coming.

After signing with the Nationals 10 years ago as an international free agent, García rapidly climbed the ranks as a contact-hitting youngster with some speed and plenty of gap power, but concerns with his eye at the dish.

The Nationals shuffled him up the minor league ladder quickly, and he made his MLB debut in 2020. In the process, he became the first player born in the 2000s to hit a home run, and he finished his rookie year with a .276 batting average, but his .668 OPS told a more complete and less promising picture.

The Nationals stuck with García for the next handful of years, but he had to battle through a ton of adversity and multiple demotions back to the minor leagues. Along the way, he moved out of a middle-infield role and dropped both shortstop and second base in favor of becoming a strict first baseman.

García’s first breakthrough came in 2024 when he hit 18 home runs (beating his previous career-high by 9 HR), and he’s remained a steady power hitter ever since, but this year he’s become a far more complete hitter, and the Nats stand to benefit from that.

Still Part of the Rebuild Plans?

Yes, the Nationals are doing better than we thought they would, but that doesn’t mean they’re completely ready to take the next step towards contention. As a matter of fact, there’s a high likelihood that they finish this year well out of the hunt and under .500.

Since they’re still in a rebuild, it’s now just a matter of whether or not the team intends for García to be a part of their next contention window. Since he took years to put it together and is going to be 27 by the time next season rolls around, why not capitalize on his value, which is currently at an all-time high?

The fact of the matter is that García’s been around for years and had never put it together until this year, his seventh in the big leagues. He’s finally finding his power stroke, but the last time he was an above-average hitter (2024), he followed it up with a dud of a performance the next season.

His chase rate remains a concern, and it’s hard to ignore the fact that he does virtually all of his damage against right-handed pitching. Being virtually unplayable against left-handed pitchers certainly limits the overall value, but you don’t have to look very hard to find teams that still need players with 20-homer pop at this year’s deadline.

He’s still got one remaining year of arbitration and is not set to hit the open market until the 2027-2028 offseason. Since he’s not a pure rental, the trade value’s higher now than it will be at this time next year.

García’s an inconsistent player, and even though he’s well liked, the time to move him should be right now.

Internal Replacements Put Extra Pressure on García

Perhaps making a deal make even more sense is the fact that the Nationals have a handful of players in the minor leagues that could easily replace García both this year and in the ones moving forward.

Abimelec Ortiz, 24, has 17 home runs and 66 RBI with a 117 wRC+ in 74 games at Triple-A this year. He’s the Nationals’ 25th-ranked prospect per MLB Pipeline and comes with a ton of power in his bat.

Yohandy Morales, 24, has 21 home runs, a .294 average, .908 OPS, and 131 wRC+ through 84 games this season in Triple-A. A teammate of Ortiz, he’s also a middle infielder with plenty of thump to offer in his stick.

Even further down the ranks, Jacob Walsh and Hunter Hines both have logged considerable playing time at first base and sport an OPS right around or above .800. They’re both a little bit further away from the big leagues than either Ortiz (who has already made his MLB debut) or Morales, but the point is that there are a number of players in the minors that will be able to take on first base once García is moved.

This is all without mentioning Curtis Mead, who’s enjoying his own breakout at the big league level. The Australian has a 138 wRC+ with an .870 OPS through 84 games and has been a revelation for the Nationals.

Mead is younger than García and made his MLB debut three years after García did, which just shows how quickly he was pushed to the majors all those years back.

Luis García Jr. Trade Fits

Arizona Diamondbacks

The Diamondbacks are trying to keep up with the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NL West, but that is much easier said than done. The gap between the two teams is currently 11.5 games and that’s not likely to shrink anytime soon, but the Dbacks remain a team that should buy at the deadline.

Since they’re not typically known as a team that’s going to go out and make a flashy, massive trade, an acquisition of García is more Arizona’s speed. He’s not going to empty the farm and is not going to cost the Dbacks an arm and a leg, so he’s the perfect fit.

On the field, the club has given the majority of its first-base reps to Ildemaro Vargas, José Fernández, Pavin Smith, Tim Tawa, and Tyler Locklear. To this point, none of them have taken the starting gig and ran away with it, leaving the door open for an acquisition.

Vargas looked like he was marching his way to an All-Star gig earlier in the year, but he’s come crashing back down to earth and has looked rough for months now.

You don’t have to squint very hard to see why someone like García would fit nicely in this lineup. The appeal here is that he’s not going to cost a ton and his additional year of arbitration eligibility ensures the Dbacks would have him for two playoff runs rather than just one.

Boston Red Sox

Garcia’s fit in Boston isn’t quite as obvious as it’d be in Arizona, but there’s still a spot for him on this team. Willson Contreras, who’s turning into one of the best offseason acquisitions in the game from this past winter, has first base locked down, but there’s playing time for someone like García at designated hitter and second base.

The Red Sox would need to do this trade knowing that García’s not great defensively anywhere outside of first base. He has a shocking -29 Defensive Runs Saved and -18 Outs Above Average at second base in just about 4200 career innings, but Boston would be bringing him aboard for what he does on the other side of the ball.

As things currently stand, the Red Sox are using a combination of Anthony Seigler, Andruw Monasterio, and Romy Gonzalez to hold down the position. Marcelo Mayer (forearm) and Isiah Kiner-Falefa (forearm) are also both rostered, but they’re each on the shelf right now.

Will the defense be hard to watch? Yes.

But do the Red Sox, who are currently 23rd in team wRC+ this year, need a lift offensively? You better believe it.

San Diego Padres

Another team chasing the Dodgers in the NL West, the Padres are toeing the line between buying and selling at this year’s deadline. Even if they end up moving pieces like Ty France or Mason Miller, their intention would undoubtedly be to make a return to contention as soon as 2027.

By doing a hybrid buy/sell at this year’s deadline, the Padres could land someone like García to take them as far down the stretch this year as possible with the assumption being that his bat is going to be much more helpful next year in a full season’s worth of games.

Since France is both a trade candidate and a pending free agent, he’s not going to be on next year’s roster either way, so it’s not difficult to see where García would fit here.

As a team, the Padres are 22nd in the majors in home runs, 25th in wRC+, and 28th in runs scored. Against right-handers, they’re 26th in wRC+ and dead last in batting average. García, who excels against righties, would represent an immediate upgrade in that department.

Since it’s apparent they’re going to be living in the Dodgers’ shadow this year, the Padres need to make some sort of a move that will help them now and in the near future. Adding a controllable asset like García makes a ton of sense, as they’re locking themselves into some respectable pop to try and boost their run ahead of next year.