Mets Bolster Farm System With Sell-Off at 2026 Trade Deadline
The Mets had the most to sell at this year's trade deadline. How did they do?
After weeks of anticipation, the 2026 trade deadline has passed, and the New York Mets’ sell-off is complete. In total, the Mets shipped off seven players over the course of the last few days.
David Stearns and the Mets’ front office brought in 12 new prospects into the system after all trades were finalized on Monday afternoon.
While this season has been nothing short of a disaster for the Mets, they did a nice job at the deadline to recoup value on their moveable assets and turn their sights toward 2027 and beyond. Reports indicate that New York has every intention to attempt to win next season, and this deadline performance helps set them up for those aspirations.
Odds are that some of the players brought into the organization in the last week will be flipped this winter in exchange for players ready to help the major-league club win next season. However, generally speaking, it feels like the Mets did as well as they could have on most of their returns.
Let’s break down all the moves the Mets made and analyze what type of returns they received.
Minter to Minnesota
Twins Receive: A.J. Minter
Mets Receive: Billy Amick, Bruin Agbayani
The Twins found themselves in the position to buy at this year’s deadline after being last year’s biggest seller. Minter returned from lat surgery in May and has been great ever since, surrendering only six earned runs all season.
Minter’s contract expires at season’s end, and based on his success this season, moving him was a no brainer.
The Mets brought in two solid prospects in exchange for the veteran southpaw.
Amick is the textbook definition of a slugger and has already showed off that tremendous pop by smacking a homer in his first game with the Mets’ organization. The 23-year-old infielder has 24 pumps on the season at the Double-A level.
The biggest area for concern with the Tennessee product is his swing-and-miss issues, which leaves a glaring hole in his profile as a hitter.
Agbayani, son of Mets alumni Benny, is the name in this deal with higher upside. The 19-year-old middle infielder is currently sidelined with a shoulder injury and only appeared in 10 games this season before landing on the injured list.
Agbayani is an athletic, six-foot-two slap hitter who may be able to pick up some power as he develops. His best attribute is his speed, which makes him a threat on the basepaths and helps him provide good range up the middle.
He is still ways away from The Show due to his lost season from an injury at Low-A , but as he continues to fill out his frame and develop, Agbayani could become a nice piece in the Mets’ system.
Peralta Heads South
Rays Receive: Freddy Peralta
Mets Receive: Gary Gill Hill, Emilien Pitre and Aidan Smith
Of the many factors that contributed to the Mets’ downfall this year, it’s hard to find one more detrimental than Peralta’s performance. He was brought in to be an ace, and New York received production that was nowhere near what they believed they were getting.
The combination of Peralta’s past success with Milwaukee and the partial industry belief that the Mets are to blame for his struggles made it possible for New York to get a solid return from Tampa Bay.
As of now, Smith is the highest touted of the trio. The 22-year-old outfielder has only slashed .215/.283/.410 at Double-A this season but has belted 10 homers in just 49 games.
Speed is a strong suit of his, as the former fourth round pick stole 41 bags in 2024 and 2025. Additionally, his defense in center field is exceptional, and he projects to stick at the position when it’s time for him to play in the big leagues.
Smith still has strides to make at the plate, but his elite speed and defense give him a rock-solid base moving forward.
Unlike Smith, the other position player acquired in this deal, Emilien Pitre, has had a strong offensive season. The 23-year-old is currently enjoying the best stretch of his pro career this season at Double-A, slashing .323/.451/.492 while flashing elite on-base skills with 13 more walks than strikeouts.
Pitre is another player with speed who has proven to be a threat on the basepaths in the minor leagues. The defense won’t blow you away, but the glove should be solid enough to man second base at the next level.
The last piece of this deal is the first pitcher New York brought in at the deadline, Gary Gill Hill. The 21-year-old right-hander has had a solid season so far in Double-A but offers some real upside for the Mets.
Hill is a strike thrower who pounds the zone with a mid-90s fastball and some respectable off-speed offerings. His arsenal still needs some tuning up, but he has a very solid base in place already. The Mets have solid organizational pitching development infrastructure in place, and helping Hill sharpen his stuff could give way to a future rotational piece for them.
Brazoban to the South Side
White Sox Receive: Huascar Brazoban
Mets Receive: Gabe Davis and Zach Franklin
With years of control left in the bank, the Mets did not have to move Brazoban at this deadline, but they opted to send him to the White Sox in exchange for two right-handed pitchers.
While Davis and Franklin both pitch, they are on two opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of style.
Davis is a towering six-foot-nine giant who has struggled in 2026, pitching to a 5.81 ERA in 18 starts across two levels. He has shown the ability to reach triple digits on the radar gun in the past, but his heater sits more in the mid-90s.
Long balls and control are two issues for Davis, who is still only 22 years old and has plenty of room to grow as a pitcher. Again, the hope is that the Mets’ organizational pitching strategy can unlock Davis’ potential and turn him into a piece for their long-term future.
Franklin is already 27 years old and yet to debut in the big leagues, but he is knocking on the door. He has saved five games in Triple-A this season, striking out hitters at a 32.1% clip. His three-pitch mix consists of a fastball, slider and splitter, a common makeup of everyday relievers at the major-league level.
Franklin is big-league ready, and with all the outgoing bullpen pieces the Mets shipped off this week, he should be considered to take one of their spots with the major-league team soon.
Raley to the Rival
Phillies Receive: Brooks Raley
Mets Receive: Luke Gabrysh and John Spikerman
Like the aforementioned Minter, Raley battled his way back from major surgery recently and turned in an extremely successful sample with the Mets this season. He was also on an expiring contract, earning him a trip down the road to Philadelphia in exchange for two prospects.
Neither Gabrysh nor Spikerman are highly touted, but they add nice depth to the Mets’ system.
Spikerman projects to have the higher upside of the two. The 23-year-old outfielder has been limited to just 32 games this season, posting a 116 wRC+. The switch-hitter does not provide a ton of value at the plate, but he has flashed elite defense and speed in the lower levels of the minors.
Gabrysh has struggled at times this season, but he has managed to strike out hitters at a respectable 29% clip. So, there is some to like for New York.
The main issue is that both are 23 years old and are only in High-A. Late bloomers do exist, but it makes you wonder if David Stearns could have netted a better return from Philly or looked elsewhere for a better package.
Pirates Get Their Closer
Pirates Receive: Luke Weaver
Mets Receive: Sammy Stafura
It is impossible to find a relief pitcher that has turned in as much production as Weaver since the calendar flipped to May. Since May 1, the veteran right-hander has surrendered just one run out of the bullpen.
While Weaver has another year on his contract, New York made the decision to trade him while his value is at its highest. Not only did the Mets let Weaver go, but they also agreed to pay almost all of his remaining salary this season and over half of what he is owed in 2027.
Why would they agree to do that, you may ask? The answer is simple: New York’s brass loves 21-year-old Sammy Stafura.
After a rough start at Low-A, Pittsburgh promoted him to the next level despite his struggles. In 47 games since, he has slashed .301/.365/.656 with 19 pumps and 16 swipes.
That kind of power output is most likely not in his future. Stearns himself admitted that to the media yesterday. But Stafura is another well-rounded acquisition to this Mets’ system.
Most of that production has come as of late, as he smacked 14 homers in the month of July alone. He has sacrificed power for some swing-and-miss issues, which is the main concern in his game. Stafura is knocking on the door of Double-A at just 21 years old, where he will really be put to the test.
The icing on the cake here is Stafura grew up a die-hard Mets fan and even was on record of rooting for them during their 2024 postseason run after he had already been drafted by Cincinnati. If he reaches the majors with the Mets, he will be an easy candidate for the Flushing Faithful to get behind.
The athleticism is undoubtable, and if the former second rounder can find a way to clean up the strikeouts and whiffs, he will shoot up prospect rankings both internally and across the league.
Saving the Best For Last
Cubs Receive: Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor
Mets Receive Jefferson Rojas
The Cubs completed their trade deadline pitching staff overhaul by adding Clay Holmes with time winding down on deadline day. They also added veteran outfielder Tyrone Taylor in the deal, who has been scorching hot since his return from the injured list on July 4.
The Mets had prepared to sell off pieces for weeks, but they had to wait until their final deal to land their biggest fish.
Jefferson Rojas is easily the most touted player that the Mets added in their sell-off and immediately slots in as the top prospect in their organization.
The 21-year-old infielder is slashing .270/.339/.461 with 15 homers and 17 steals at the Double-A level this season. Rojas is a well-rounded ballplayer with good bat-to-ball skills and increasing power. As he continues to fill out his frame and get stronger, the power should only improve.
It’s still to be seen what infield position fits him best. He could play up the middle, but he has the arm to slide over to third if needed. Rojas’ versatility only further increases his value as a prospect.
Baring injury, Rojas projects to see the major-league field at some point in 2027 after spending all of 2026 at Double-A. When he does reach The Show, the Dominican product possess all the tools to make an impact right away.
Recap
Overall, the Mets did a solid job with their sell-off at this year’s deadline. While the organization and its fanbase are obviously disappointed that they will not be contending this season, they have to be at least somewhat satisfied with what they accomplished in the last few days.
A lot went wrong for the Mets this year, but there is also a good amount that has gone right. They still have two future Hall of Famers in Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto on their roster, as well as a group of budding young players.
This deadline haul only further strengthens the organization’s assets moving forward, as the Mets will look to jump right back into contending in 2027.
The organizational emphasis on acquiring athlete-first position players only continued at this trade deadline. The Mets want to get younger, more versatile, and improve defensively. While David Stearns’ now infamous “run prevention” line certainly is overplayed, if done right, it is a winning strategy. That was evident in his time with the Milwaukee Brewers.
Ultimately, prospects are lottery tickets, but with the right development, some of these players could help the Mets finally find consistent winning.
Become a Member of Just Baseball
Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!
* Save 25% by subscribing annually.
Written by
Joe Browne is an aspiring sports journalist and is currently a freshman at St. John's University. Joe is a lifelong Mets fan who is also passionate…