Five Mock Trades for San Francisco Giants Ace Logan Webb

The San Francisco Giants are reportedly listening to trade offers for Logan Webb, so here are five mock trades that could get a deal done.

CINCINNATI, OH - MARCH 27: Logan Webb #62 of the San Francisco Giants pitches during the game between the San Francisco Giants and the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park on Thursday, March 27, 2025 in Cincinnati, Ohio. (Photo by Lauren Leigh Bacho/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

Robert Murray reported that the San Francisco Giants are open to trade offers for their ace, Logan Webb. At first, that sounds like a shock. Webb is only 30 and has two years and $47 million left on his contract. That’s not cheap, but every team in baseball would happily take on that deal.

Still, the fact that the Giants are listening doesn’t surprise me. San Francisco has major roster decisions to make. They won just 65 games in 2026, the fourth-worst record in baseball.

That might be okay with a tiny payroll, but the Giants spent more than $190 million, 14th in MLB. Paying that much for one of the worst teams in the league should be a wake-up call for this front office.

They don’t have to trade Webb, but they should absolutely be listening, and honestly, they should be listening to everyone. You could argue that if the Giants add this winter and the roster stays healthy, they could chase a Wild Card in 2027. But that’s a parlay that probably won’t cash.

Ad – content continues below

A haul for Webb would add on to an already great farm system, setting themselves up for the future. So what would that haul look like, and is it worth it?

The best comparison I found is Justin Verlander in 2017. The Tigers traded him to Houston for three of the Astros’ top 11 prospects. The trade ended up lopsided in Houston’s favor, and only Jake Rogers really panned out. But that’s not the point. The point is the value that went back. Developing those players is the Giants’ job.

The comparison isn’t perfect. Verlander was owed $56 million over his last two years, more than Webb is now. But he was also a better pitcher than Webb at the time, and since he was traded on August 31, Houston got an extra month plus a playoff run.

Detroit also sent $8 million a year to Houston to land a better prospect package.

It’s not apples-to-apples, but two top-10 prospects plus another interesting piece seems like a fair price for Webb. We also have to consider that the Giants likely wouldn’t part with Webb unless they were floored with the return. We can also be strategic and package some big-league-ready players with prospects.

Basically, this is a framework for a Logan Webb trade with five teams that makes a lot of sense.

Trade Idea #1: Logan Webb to the Chicago White Sox for LHP Noah Schultz, RHP Joey Volchko, 2B/SS Kyle Lodise

Noah Schultz is the headliner here. He’s a 6’10”, 240-pound lefty, and at times he looked like a front-line starter. Other times he looked like a Triple-A arm. That’s the Schultz experience. He’s a project, but if it clicks, he has the size and deception to lead a rotation for years.

He’s only 23, so the ceiling is sky-high. The floor is a pitcher who never fully develops and ends up fighting for a bullpen role. I wouldn’t read much into his 5.57 ERA with the White Sox in 2026, though. He was phenomenal in Triple-A in 2026 with a 2.01 ERA. For what it’s worth, I’m a believer.

Ad – content continues below

Joey Volchko is one of the White Sox’s better pitching prospects. He touched 101 mph in college at Georgia, and Chicago took him in the third round of the 2026 draft.

Lodise rounds out the deal as a nice add, an infield prospect with a high baseball IQ.

Trade Idea #2: Logan Webb to the Baltimore Orioles for 2B Jackson Holliday and LHP Caden Hunter

“But Peter, what about Marcelo Mayer?”

What about him? I’d take Holliday every time. Mayer is at the point in his career where he still has to prove he’s an everyday player. Holliday is a year younger and a former number one overall pick. If you can get him, you do it.

Then there’s Caden Hunter, an extremely intriguing pitching prospect. The lefty had a 2.01 ERA across three levels and finished in Double-A with a 3.09 ERA and 49 strikeouts in 35 innings. He’s only 23, so he could crack the rotation as soon as next year and be a full-time starter by 2028. Hunter is one of the best prospects in this entire article.

Trade Idea #3: Logan Webb to the Atlanta Braves for SS Tate Southisene, RHP Owen Murphy, OF Owen Carey

I know the Giants want pitching above all else, but Tate Southisene would be a huge get. He’s No. 81 on our Top 100 prospects list, and the kid flies. If he can unlock more power, you’re looking at an above-average big leaguer. The big question is whether he sticks at shortstop.

Either way, he’s a great athlete, and it’s hard to find a 20-year-old with his mix of speed and power potential. The Braves took him in the first round for a reason.

Owen Murphy gives the Giants the pitching they want. He’s another former first-rounder, and he debuted with Atlanta at 22 after a stellar Triple-A season. With five pitches and plus command, he could become a regular in the Giants’ rotation for years.

Ad – content continues below

The third piece is Owen Carey. He’s a good defensive outfielder with some speed, and he’s still only 20.

Trade Idea #4: Logan Webb to the Toronto Blue Jays for LHP Johnny King, LHP Ricky Tiedemann, C Franklin Rojas

Johnny King is disgusting, with a capital D. He’s a 20-year-old with a big fastball and a nasty curveball, and he’s the Blue Jays’ best pitching prospect. He reached Double-A last year and had a 2.95 ERA with 27 strikeouts in 21.1 innings. He’s also developing a changeup, and if that pitch clicks, look out. He signed at 17 and has impressed at every stop. He alone would be a big get for the Giants.

Next up is Ricky Tiedemann. A few years ago, he was considered the best left-handed pitching prospect in baseball before injuries derailed him. But he’s still only 24, and he reached the big leagues last season.

Franklin Rojas rounds out the deal. He’s only 19, but he had an .840 OPS in rookie ball last year, and he walks almost as often as he strikes out.

Trade Idea #5: Logan Webb to the Chicago Cubs for UTIL Matt Shaw, RHP Cade Townsend, 3B/SS Juan Tomas

Matt Shaw’s value is interesting. For some reason, the baseball world is eager to write him off. But in 77 games, he had a 106 wRC+, a walk rate over 10%, and just a 17.3% strikeout rate. He can play every position except pitcher and catcher, and he’s still only 25. Just a few years ago, he was one of baseball’s top prospects.

The issue is that the Giants already have a guy who plays everywhere: Casey Schmitt. But if Webb gets traded, I think Schmitt is probably next out the door, which opens that role for Shaw. With regular playing time, Shaw can still be an above-average everyday player.

Cade Townsend was the Cubs’ first-round pick last year. He hasn’t debuted yet, but his stuff is loud, and he has an impressive feel for spin. If his command keeps improving, he should debut by 2028.

Juan Tomas is an 18-year-old switch-hitter with above-average speed and a solid glove. He’s the “flier” in this deal, but after putting up an .804 OPS last year, he’s almost too good for that label.

Ad – content continues below

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.