Free Agent Starting Pitchers the Reds Could Target
From a familiar face to a few bounce-back candidates, here are five realistic starting pitchers who could sign with the Reds this offseason.
The Cincinnati Reds‘ 2025 playoff berth was mostly due to their great starting pitching. A rotation that often carried the Reds’ lackluster offense was led by Cincinnati’s ace Hunter Greene, a healthy Nick Lodolo, a career year from Andrew Abbott, and a stable vet in Brady Singer. What was seen as a strength quickly dissipated as injuries and regression hit in 2026.
Although Chase Burns is looking like one of the best emerging aces in baseball, the support staff around him comes with plenty of question marks. Which version of Nick Lodolo do we get? Will he even be healthy? Is Andrew Abbott finally leveling out to his expected numbers? Will Rhett Lowder find a way to miss enough bats to be effective? How will you replace the Brady Singer innings and fill the fifth spot?
Cincinnati’s list of needs this winter is rather long. Infield, outfield, starting pitcher, and bullpen help. Oh yeah, and catcher. It’s probably easier to make a list of what they don’t need than what they do. While there will be a time to discuss the other positions, I want to start with the rotation.
The Reds will miss Hunter Greene for the 2027 season due to injury, and with Brady Singer hitting the open market, there are at least 200 innings to fill. Well, more, but I assume Rhett Lowder and Brandon Williamson will see an increase in their workloads, which is not exactly ideal.
I’d argue that the team needs two starters. Not only to raise the ceiling, but to give the Reds the type of depth that they need. I don’t love the idea of Chase Petty, Rhett Lowder, and Brandon Williamson (or a different filler) eating innings, especially with essentially no depth behind them.
Of course, it will come down to money. We already know that starters are expensive, and convincing certain arms to come to Great American Ball Park usually takes a premium. Because of this, and the other needs on the team, I predict the Reds will only sign one legitimate starter. Here are the most realistic options.
Jack Flaherty

2026 Stats: 20 G/19 GS, 88.1 IP, 4.48 ERA, 4.05 FIP, 10.49 K/9, 4.28 BB/9
I’d argue that Jack Flaherty would be the most likely candidate to land with the Reds. He hit free agency two seasons ago and did not have much interest at all, coming off one of the best seasons of his career, and had to settle for a two-year deal returning to Detroit.
In my opinion, he pitched better than his stats would suggest. His biggest issue was that his command once again disappeared, leading to several games where he struggled to throw strikes and work past the third inning. Without a doubt, that is a concern, but the Reds don’t have the type of money to sign flawless pitchers.
What Flaherty does offer is swing-and-miss stuff. I think the Reds need to take a risk on players who can produce strikeouts, bring a veteran presence, and are not far removed from major league success. Considering his lack of a market two seasons ago and coming off a down year, I think Flaherty will not only fit into the price range but also the contract length the Reds would be comfortable with.
Like so many Reds pitchers, Flaherty comes with an injury history. He was healthy for three of the past four seasons, but last year he did spend time on the injured list. When you factor in his poor free-agent market two seasons ago, an injury and down season in 2026, and his age, I think he falls into the range where the Reds would be able to land him.
Dustin May
2026 Stats: 31 GS, 145.2 IP, 4.70 ERA, 2.63 FIP, 8.90 K/9, 3.09 BB/9
Few pitchers have been able to carry the “what if” caveat for as long as Dustin May has. A former top prospect with the Dodgers who showed flashes, but constant injuries made him more of a myth than an actual pitcher. You heard about him, but you rarely saw him. Boston traded for him in a relatively big deal before letting him walk after 28.1 innings.
May pitched well in St. Louis and joined the Brewers at the deadline but struggled to keep the ball in the park. Although May is no longer the same pitcher we thought he could be as a prospect, he’s still a quality arm with enough swing-and-miss stuff to help round out a rotation.
Watch a start from Dustin May, and you’ll quickly understand why teams keep giving him a chance. You’ll catch glimpses of pitches with late, darting action that make you believe there’s always going to be something more. Well, we’ve been doing that for about seven seasons now.
May is a good back-of-the-rotation starter who could surprise you every once in a while. Cincinnati doesn’t have someone like that, which is why I think this could be a marriage. If you can’t afford the pitcher with elite stuff and a track record to back it up, you have to settle for the pitcher with good stuff and a shaky past. If the Reds give May a multi-year deal, I could see him wanting to go to Cincinnati.
David Peterson
2026 Stats: 32 G/23 GS, 148.1 IP, 4.79 ERA, 3.96 FIP, 8.31 K/9, 3.94 BB/9
I know a David Peterson signing isn’t going to get you up on your feet, but he would help stabilize the rotation. Last season came with its fair share of blow-up starts and short outings due to his inability to throw strikes, but I’m willing to see past a down season. I’ve always thought that Peterson got a worse reputation than he should have.
Although Great American Ball Park is not quite the hitter’s park many have labeled it, it is fair to say that it does favor hitters. What does Peterson do best? Produce ground balls. For his career, Peterson has produced a 51.3% ground-ball rate while limiting home runs well in two of the past three seasons.
I think Peterson’s deal will come in at a lower AAV than Flaherty’s and May’s and also come with less commitment. He’s the only lefty I have on this list, mostly due to my preferred lefties being out of the Reds’ price range. Do you think Cincinnati is willing to go with three lefties in the rotation? Considering Lodolo’s injury history, they cannot count on him giving them 150 innings.
Brady Singer

2026 Stats: 31 GS, 157 IP, 5.85 ERA, 5.62 FIP, 7.22 K/9, 3.55 BB/9
How about a reunion that fans would certainly not like? Many thought that Brady Singer would be traded at last year’s deadline, but he finished the season in Cincinnati. In fact, there was a time when reports suggested that the Reds considered keeping him even if it meant extending a qualifying offer. Wouldn’t that have been a disaster? The Reds dodged the qualifying offer, but they might not dodge a reunion.
By all accounts, Singer enjoyed his time in Cincinnati. I can’t recall there ever being any reports of his displeasure, making a return possible. Let’s keep in mind that there were stretches where Singer was good. I’d argue that he was a solid four or five in 2025 and an important piece of the Reds’ rotation. And forget about 2026, but this isn’t a talentless arm.
The way I see it, Brady Singer is a fallback option if the Reds get outbid or if there aren’t many pitchers interested in coming to Cincinnati. The Reds might have to settle for a Singer return. I do prefer him over Brandon Williamson, Chase Petty, and what we’ve seen from Rhett Lowder, for what it’s worth.
If I’m Singer, I’m looking for a one- or two-year deal elsewhere. I’d rather try to establish my value in a more pitcher-friendly ballpark, especially now that the pitching coach has changed in Cincinnati.
Zach Eflin
2026 Stats: Injured
There was a point in time when Zach Eflin was viewed as a pretty good fourth, maybe even third, option. A consistent pitcher who got ground balls, didn’t walk batters, and provided a rather predictable start made him someone several teams were interested in. Injuries have taken their toll throughout his career, and 2025 and 2026 were no different, as he was limited to only 3.2 innings last season.
Let me go ahead and say it. His injury is a huge red flag, and that’s why I would not put Eflin high on this list. It’s also the exact reason why he’s on the list, however. The Reds made a similar move when they signed Frankie Montas coming off an injury. I know, I know, that didn’t go too well. But that doesn’t mean the Reds should avoid injured players from here on out. It’s the best way to get a discount, and the Reds love a discount.
What Eflin would offer the Reds is a floor, if healthy. A veteran who could step in, fill the fifth spot, and not force the Reds to make any commitments down the road. A modest one-year deal might just be exactly what the Reds can afford after addressing other needs on the roster.
Become a Member of Just Baseball
Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!
* Save 25% by subscribing annually.
