Top 5 Newfound Free Agents: Most Notable Non-Tendered Players

Yesterday a whole new wave of free agents hit the market after the non-tender deadline. Here are five of the names that are most intriguing.

Luis Gil of the New York Yankees is a prime candidate to win the AL Rookie of the Year Award in 2024.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - AUGUST 08: Luis Gil #81 of the New York Yankees pitches during the second inning against the Seattle Mariners at Yankee Stadium on August 08, 2021 in New York City. (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

Last night was the last significant date in the offseason calendar before D-Day, which is when the CBA expires on December 1st and the lockout is expected to begin.

In the meantime, teams spent yesterday navigating the non-tender deadline, their last chance to cut ties with players before tendering them contracts for the 2027 season.

For some players who did well early on in their careers, but have since struggled (Jarren Duran is a good example), teams have to weigh the cost of what they are being paid in arbitration with their current production, and sometimes they decide its better to reallocate those resources elsewhere.

You also have players who struggle to stay on the field, putting teams in the position of having to decide if the injury risk is worth the cost.

Ad – content continues below

Today, we are going to dive into the top 5 non-tendered players who I am most intrigued with entering the free agent market. These are guys who I think will be getting an MLB contract, despite just being let go from there’s.

If you are curious who your favorite team non-tendered, at the end of the piece you will find every player who was non-tendered listed by team.

5. Kyle Isbel, Kansas City Royals

Since 2022, there are a total of three outfielders in Major League Baseball that have racked up 50 or more OAA. Pete Crow-Armstrong leads the pack with 64, then Daulton Varsho comes in second with 58, and then you have Kyle Isbel at exactly 50 OAA.

While Isbel provides very little offensively, his glove alone will warrant more big league opportunities, especially in a market that is very thin on center fielders.

4. Luke Raley, Seattle Mariners

This was one of the more surprising non-tenders for me, as I would have thought the Mariners could have traded Raley, even if they didn’t want to have him on their roster for next season. The 32-year-old did not have the best season, but still finished the year with a wRC+ over 100 (106), and 15 home runs.

He is also one of those data darlings who’s quick swing produces plenty of red on his Baseball Savant page. With that said, he also struck out 32.4% of the time last year, whiffed 40.9%, and posted an abysmal 5.2% walk rate.

It’s not crazy that he was cut, but teams also won’t be crazy to give him a guaranteed MLB contract for next season to try recapture the success he had back in 2023 and 2024 (posted a 129 wRC+ each season).

3. Luis Gil, New York Yankees

For Luis Gil to get non-tendered, when he was only projected to make a little over $2 million in arbitration, is a damning statement about his health. Sure, Gil didn’t have any minor league options remaining, but there is a good chance he’d be scooped up if he ever hit waivers anyway.

Ad – content continues below

Two years ago, Gil won the AL Rookie of the Year, posting 29 starts and pitching to a 3.50 ERA for the Yankees in his age-26 season. It looked like he had finally arrived. Unfortunately, right now, he is looking more like a flash in the pan.

Gil has only made 20 appearances since his 2024 campaign, and only 15 of them have been starts. Across the two seasons he has pitched 84 1/3 innings. Gil is currently pitching in Winter Ball, so you’d have to assume he has a clean bill of health at the moment.

The Yankees didn’t think he was worth the risk, but I am sure there are teams with nothing to lose who are going to roll the dice on his upside.

2. Bailey Ober, Minnesota Twins

While Bailey Ober may not have the same recognition as Gil, he provides the thing that teams truly covet more than anything. Innings.

Over the past four seasons, Baily Ober has pitched over 600 innings for the Minnesota Twins, making him on of the 27 starting pitchers in baseball who have completed that feat.

Now to be fair, Ober was far more effective across the first two seasons of that four-year span than the last, but that durability while get him another big league job at the back-end of a thinner rotation.

1. Trevor Larnach, Minnesota Twins

This is the one I just flatly don’t get. Trevor Larnach legitimately had a good season in 2026. In fact, it was a career-year by wRC+ (123) and fWAR (2.2). He hit .269/.352/.436, with 13 home runs and 48 RBIs in 122 games played.

Larnach’s season did end due to a wrist injury that required surgery, but he was still expected to be ready for Spring Training.

Ad – content continues below

For a guy that commands the strike zone so well, takes his walks and making plenty of contact, who is also not a butcher in the corner outfield, it is pretty surprising the Twins couldn’t line up a trade. What they did however line up is some extra room to spend in free agency.

By non-tendering Ober (projected $7.65 million), Larnach ($6.375 million) and by trading Royce Lewis ($5.2 million), the Twins freed up close to $20 million on their books to further allocate in free agency.

American League Non-Tenders

Los Angeles Angels: None
Houston Astros: OF Taylor Trammell
Athletics: None
Toronto Blue Jays: INF/OF Davis Schneider
Cleveland Guardians: INF/OF David Fry
Seattle Mariners: OF Luke Raley
Baltimore Orioles: None
Texas Rangers: RHP José Buttó
Tampa Bay Rays: RHP Cole Sulser
Boston Red Sox: C Connor Wong
Kansas City Royals: RHP Nick Mears, OF Kyle Isbel, LHP Anthony Gose
Detroit Tigers: LHP Jake Miller, INF Trey Sweeney, OF Matt Vierling
Minnesota Twins: OF Trevor Larnach, RHP Bailey Ober, INF Matt Wallner
Chicago White Sox: None
New York Yankees: RHP Fernando Cruz, RHP Luis Gil

National League Non-Tenders

Atlanta Braves: RHP Michael Grove, RHP James Karinchak
Milwaukee Brewers: None
St. Louis Cardinals: INF Nolan Gorman, RHP Max Rajcic
Chicago Cubs: INF Gabriel Arias, RHP Ethan Roberts
Arizona D-backs: LHP Andrew Saalfrank, LHP Blake Walston
Los Angeles Dodgers: RHP Jake Cousins
San Francisco Giants: OF Victor Bericoto, RHP Rowan Wick
Miami Marlins: None
New York Mets: INF Christopher Morel, RHP Dylan Ross, C Hayden Senger
Washington Nationals: RHP Josiah Gray, LHP Carson Palmquist, LHP Jared Simpson
San Diego Padres: LHP JP Sears, RHP Garrett Hawkins
Philadelphia Phillies: OF Bryan De La Cruz, INF Brett Harris, RHP Andrew Hoffman, RHP Moisés Chace
Pittsburgh Pirates: RHP Noah Murdock
Cincinnati Reds: INF Leo Balcazar
Colorado Rockies: RHP Jimmy Herget

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.