Top Landing Spots for Free Agent Tyler Stephenson

Stephenson could be one of the more intriguing catchers on the free-agent market this offseason. Where might the former Reds catcher land?

Tyler Stephenson of the Cincinnati Reds bats in the first inning during a game against the New York Mets at Citi Field.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 17: Tyler Stephenson #37 of the Cincinnati Reds bats in the first inning during a game against the New York Mets at Citi Field on September 17, 2023 in New York City. (Photo by Brandon Sloter/Image Of Sport/Getty Images)

Every offseason, we discuss winners and losers and usually focus on which teams did or did not do enough over the winter. On the other side of the coin are players, who can also be labeled as winners and losers based on the contracts they sign. I have a feeling Tyler Stephenson is going to fall into the winners category.

If your favorite team is in need of a catcher, you better act quickly. A quick glance at the available free-agent catchers will show that starters are few and far between, and even backup options are limited. While Tyler Stephenson might not be the home run signing you have imagined, he is a quality starter who has shown improvement behind the plate.

You might think that a 6-foot-3, 225-pound frame would produce a power hitter, but that’s not necessarily the case with Stephenson. He’s yet to hit 20 home runs in a season or post an ISO greater than .191. Occasionally, he’ll get a hold of a ball and launch it into the left-field seats, convincing you that more power is soon to come. Well, I’ve been tricked by those swings for seven years, and I think I’ve learned my lesson. He is what he is.

So, what type of player is Tyler Stephenson? A solid yet unspectacular hitter who isn’t going to chase much out of the zone or swing through too many strikes. He makes enough hard contact to make you think the results are just around the corner. He’s always used all fields, and maybe a team can get him to lean into pulling the ball more, but the Reds have not been able to unlock that part of his game.

Ad – content continues below

He’s a perfectly fine starter who should bat in the bottom third of a competitive lineup. He has shown flashes of being a plus hitter, but those flashes either don’t last or injuries have stalled his progress. Although his bat definitely carries his value, I do believe he has improved behind the plate.

Free Agent Profile: Tyler Stephenson

  • Age in 2027: 30
  • 2026 Stats: .241/.323/.404, 15 HR, 99 wRC+
  • Contract Projection: 1-3 years
  • Expected AAV: $7-$12 million

You won’t confuse Tyler Stephenson with a Gold Glove defender. You’ll quickly notice that he does not have the most natural movements for a catcher, but I do think he is passable. He’ll struggle to hold runners at times and will allow his fair share of stolen bases, but one area that has made him more valuable has been the ABS system.

Last season, Tyler Stephenson challenged 136 ball/strike calls and had 93 overturned, which ranked second only to William Contreras. His 68% win rate was the highest of any catcher who challenged at least 100 pitches, resulting in 21 strikeouts.

While the ABS system is still young and the sample size is small, I think it’s fair to say that catchers who have had this positive of an impact carry higher value. Framing is still important, and it’s something that Stephenson has always struggled with, but his ability to win these challenges and know when to utilize them helps make up for his framing struggles.

A 30-year-old catcher in a weak market who is at least an average-to-above-average hitter, carries value with ABS challenges, and is passable behind the plate is going to get a decent payday. Catchers are difficult to find, and plenty of teams need them. Maybe even these teams listed below.

Free Agent Landing Spots for Tyler Stephenson

Cincinnati Reds

Just before the trade deadline this season, Tyler Stephenson was interviewed after a game and was in tears because he thought he was getting traded. This speaks volumes about how much he has enjoyed his time in Cincinnati, but it also speaks to how the Reds have cornered themselves into needing to re-sign him.

The Reds’ catching situation is dire. Jose Trevino is a backup at best, and Will Banfield is a minor-league depth piece. Alfredo Duno, the Reds’ top prospect, will hopefully assume the role in the future, but the Reds cannot afford to put all their eggs in one basket with a 20-year-old who has dealt with injuries.

I believe that Stephenson would be open to a reunion, but it’s up to the Reds to decide if they want to pay him. Although payroll is always tight, the need for a catcher is massive, and his familiarity with the pitching staff only helps. Even if it costs the Reds a slight premium, I think they should pay it and bring Stephenson back as the starter, with the expectation that he eventually transitions into a backup role for Duno (2028 or 2029).

Ad – content continues below

Minnesota Twins

The Twins’ primary focus is likely bringing back their own Ryan Jeffers, who is also on the free-agent market. Jeffers is a better player than Stephenson but does come with his own health concerns. If the Twins miss out on Jeffers, Stephenson could be a nice fallback option.

Minnesota has fluctuated between needing to sell and needing to buy over the past couple of years, but there are reports that they will increase payroll, even if only slightly. The Twins have a good mix of solid, established veterans and young players with upside and should look to contend in 2027 and beyond. A combination of Stephenson and Caratini would help them do so.

Considering the Twins’ young talent and prospects will fill a majority of the lineup in 2027 and the near future, I think they can put resources into the catching position without fear of it preventing them from improving the roster elsewhere.

New York Yankees

Austin Wells was supposed to be the impact catcher the Yankees have been looking for, but his 2026 season left plenty of concerns. I still view Wells as a starting-caliber catcher and think that the Yankees will stick with him, but adding a veteran with starting experience would be the type of insurance New York needs.

The Yankees are too proud a franchise to continue cycling through AAAA-level backup catchers each season. It’s time to take the backup role more seriously and consider a potential replacement if Wells does not return to form. At the very least, Stephenson could be a short-side platoon option (.785 OPS vs. LHP in his career) to pair with Wells.

I’m sure that Stephenson would rather go somewhere with a clearer path to starting. While I wouldn’t put the Yankees at the top of my predictions, I do think they could offer enough money to make a deal happen. At some point, a second catcher needs to be a priority, and I think that point is now.

Philadelphia Phillies

The Phillies have an interesting winter ahead of them. I truly have no idea what type of direction this team will take. They are old, continue to come up short, but also have too much talent locked up to simply declare a rebuild. So, throwing more money at the problem and hoping for the best might be their most likely path forward.

I think we can all agree that the J.T. Realmuto signing was a panic move that the Phillies have grown to regret. Sure, he’s a great clubhouse guy and a good defender, but he’s at the end of his career. Rafael Marchan was historically bad in 2026, and Garrett Stubbs is now a free agent. The options are bleak.

Ad – content continues below

Signing Stephenson would allow the Phillies to have a younger option behind the plate while giving J.T. Realmuto more days off. I think it’s fair to say that Stephenson is the better option than Realmuto at this point. The Phillies have several moves they’ll need to make this offseason, including some trades, so addressing catcher early would give them cost certainty as they work through their other decisions.

Chicago Cubs

Would Tyler Stephenson go from the Reds to the NL Central rival Cubs? That would be a tough pill to swallow if you’re a Reds fan, but the fit does make sense. Carson Kelly was a nice find for the Cubs over the past couple of seasons but has now entered free agency, and Chicago could turn toward a younger option.

Miguel Amaya is still under contract and will likely take on a bigger role in 2027. He also has the potential to be a quality starter. However, I do not think the Cubs will want to go into a season with high expectations relying solely on Amaya and a lower-tier free-agent backup.

Similar to the Twins, the Cubs could be interested in simply bringing back their own player in Carson Kelly. But this team is too good not to be a frontrunner for one of the best, and only, backup plans on the open market.

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.