Will the Padres Actually Come Away With Any Big Fish?

The Padres have reportedly been involved in talks with several top free agents. But which ones have a realistic shot at landing in San Diego?

PITTSBURGH, PA - MAY 01: Seiya Suzuki #27 of the Chicago Cubs rounds the bases after hitting a home run in the fifth inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the game at PNC Park on May 1, 2025 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Justin K. Aller/Getty Images)
PITTSBURGH, PA - MAY 01: Seiya Suzuki #27 of the Chicago Cubs rounds the bases after hitting a home run in the fifth inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the game at PNC Park on May 1, 2025 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Justin K. Aller/Getty Images)

It’s clear the San Diego Padres are spending this offseason and hunting for multiple big-fish free agents.

This week, the team has met with superstars Tarik Skubal and Seiya Suzuki, both of whom are looking to sign before the highly anticipated December 1 lockout.

Landing either of these players would dramatically improve the team and represent the first big splash under new owners José E. Feliciano and Kwanza Jones.

Giving an already hyper-aggressive A.J. Preller more financial flexibility allows you to at least dream about the possibility of signing players like Skubal or Suzuki. However, the Padres aren’t the only suitors, and both players are expected to command massive contracts.

Ad – content continues below

The Padres have put themselves in the conversation, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll come away with anything.

So, how realistic are their chances of landing either player? And could this be the offseason where Preller pulls off another massive free-agent signing?

Let’s dive in. 

The Possibility of Signing Tarik Skubal

Landing arguably the top starting pitcher in the sport can’t be a bad thing, especially given how depleted the rotation is after Michael King opted out and the team declined Nick Pivetta‘s option.

Skubal would likely fill King’s spot, giving the Padres a new ace. And over the last three seasons, he’s been nothing short of dominant, pitching to a 2.42 ERA across 546 innings.

My only reservation with Skubal isn’t that his performance will decline, but rather his health. He underwent nano arthroscopy early this season to remove loose bodies from his left elbow. It’s his third major elbow procedure, with the previous ones being flexor tendon surgery in 2022 and Tommy John surgery in college.

Yes, he’s been great when returning from all of his injuries, but it’s something worth considering when he’s going to cost well over $300 million.

Signing Skubal would be incredible, but he would only be one piece of a much bigger puzzle. The team needs multiple high-level starters to be legitimate contenders, and given how much Skubal will cost, it would make it incredibly difficult to fill out the rest of the rotation without having an insanely expensive offseason.

Ad – content continues below

That doesn’t even include the holes at first base and left field.

Overall, the odds of signing Skubal seem to be very low. The Padres would have to win a bidding war against the Blue Jays, Dodgers, and Mets, and I don’t count on that happening.

The Possibility of Signing Seiya Suzuki

According to Jeff Passan, the Padres could be the favorites to land Suzuki.

The Padres need outfield help and another right-handed power threat in the lineup, and Suzuki very easily checks all those boxes.

Over the last four seasons, he’s posted an .833 OPS while averaging 25 home runs and 85 RBIs. What makes Seiya even more appealing is his added defensive value, putting up a career-best 7 Fielding Run Value and 5 Outs Above Average.

The only “issue” is that Suzuki has played right field his entire career, and while he’s improved as a defender, Fernando Tatis Jr. is the best defensive right fielder in baseball.

This leaves the team with two options: put Suzuki in left field and have the best outfield in baseball, or keep Seiya in right and have Tatis play in the infield full-time.

Let’s say the team opts to put Tatis in the infield. What do you do with Jake Cronenworth? Either he becomes the full-time first baseman or the team explores trading him.

Ad – content continues below

There are certainly some roster construction questions that would need to be answered, but those are good problems to have. I’d much rather have too many quality players than not enough.

Either way, the Padres should aggressively pursue Suzuki.

What makes this potential signing even more appealing is that it won’t come close to costing what Skubal would. The Padres would add another middle-of-the-order bat while allowing Preller to address the rotation and potentially bring back Ty France.

It feels like the Padres’ chances of landing Suzuki are substantially higher than their chances of signing Skubal.

Final Thoughts

In a perfect world, the Padres have an unlimited payroll and can sign Skubal and Suzuki without sweating it. Unfortunately, that’s not the case.

Between the two, Suzuki has a much higher chance of being signed, and I think it would make significantly more sense for the Padres to prioritize him.

I love the fact that the team is even involved in the Skubal sweepstakes. It shows that new ownership is serious about winning and is willing to give Preller the financial flexibility to make moves. That’s something Padres fans should be excited about.

Let the Blue Jays, Dodgers, and Mets battle it out for Skubal. The Padres should go get the best bat on the market and trust that there are enough pitching options available to build a championship-caliber rotation.

Ad – content continues below

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.