What the Dustin May Signing Means for the Chicago White Sox

How we evaluate this deal will depend on the other moves Chicago makes this offseason.

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - MAY 09: Dustin May #3 of the St. Louis Cardinals pitches during a game against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park on May 09, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA - MAY 09: Dustin May #3 of the St. Louis Cardinals pitches during a game against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park on May 09, 2026 in San Diego, California. (Photo by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Images)

It became abundantly clear last week that the Chicago White Sox would be prioritizing starting pitching this winter, and they’ve taken their first step in doing so by signing 29-year-old Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract.

This move, while a step in the right direction, will ultimately be graded by those that follow the rest of this offseason.

The White Sox are a team looking to avoid regression and ideally take another step forward coming off such massive improvement last year. Filling the holes that became glaring late in the year and into the postseason is essential to doing that. This signing should be the first of many moves to come for Chicago.

Dustin May Outlook

The initial reaction to this signing was one of surprise for many, as they saw May struggle down the stretch and in the postseason for Milwaukee, but there is reason to believe that he can be a true mid-rotation piece for Chicago.

Ad – content continues below

This contract may seem hefty, but the reality of free agency is that starting pitchers are going to get paid in a big way. It may feel steep, but $17.5M AAV for hopefully a stable rotation piece isn’t really an overpay.

May’s path to this point is unique, as he had never thrown more than 70 big league innings between the regular season and postseason combined in a season prior to 2025. He showed signs of an elite young arm with the Dodgers during the shortened 2020 year and in 2023 when he made nine starts.

A pair of Tommy John surgeries in 2021 and 2023 held him back from establishing any bit of consistency at the MLB level despite impressive stuff being flashed whenever healthy. A bizarre ruptured esophagus that required emergency surgery held him back from returning to the mound in 2024 as he recovered from his second elbow surgery.

The past two seasons have been the first largely healthy ones for May, despite a few minor injuries in each season, with 132.1 innings pitched in 2025 and 156.2 in 2026, including the postseason.

The surface-level numbers certainly do not stand out, but it’s much more encouraging under the hood.

His first half of 2026 spent with St. Louis was particularly encouraging, as May pitched to a 4.38 ERA but with a 3.15 FIP and posted 2.6 fWAR across 109 innings. Following the deadline trade to Milwaukee, his numbers ticked down, but his strikeout rate and ability to generate whiffs actually improved.

Additionally, May did have some of the worst luck in MLB with one of the highest BABIP marks in baseball at .318 and one of the lowest LOB% in the game at 67.6% last season. Batters getting on base when they put the ball in play and then not getting left on base is typically going to lead to many runs allowed, but is often due for positive regression.

A huge aspect of May’s growth this season came from an uptick in his cutter usage, a pitch that was somewhat of an afterthought in previous seasons but became his second-most utilized offering, just a tick behind his four-seam this year.

Ad – content continues below

Chicago has put an emphasis on starters throwing multiple, often three, fastball variations, and that’s exactly what May did last season, with each of his three fastballs being used 20% of the time or more.

Another interesting aspect of his season was that his arm angle was raised 14 degrees this season to the highest point it has been in his career. It’s worth monitoring how much the White Sox may further adjust that in addition to his arsenal next season.

Given that May is just 29 years old entering 2027 with less mileage on his arm than most free agents pitchers, the upside is there.

However, it’s still a risk to take for the White Sox, given not just the injury history but the lack of consistent high-level production, regardless of the encouraging data.

This is a signing based on the promise of what May could be, and how we evaluate it will depend on what else Chicago does to maximize this roster.

Next Steps for the White Sox

This may feel like a simplistic way to view a signing, but it may just be that straightforward.

If Dustin May represents the top starting pitcher added by Chicago, this move feels seriously lackluster. If another starting pitcher is added to slot in above May in the rotation, this move feels like a great upside swing.

Chicago has Sean Burke at the top of the rotation after a breakout 2026 season that saw him be the only true starter used in the postseason.

Ad – content continues below

Beyond that, Davis Martin is likely locked into a spot after a strong first half in 2026, but his season went downhill quickly. Grant Taylor is set to enter the rotation after a dominant year in the bullpen but has never thrown over 100 innings in his career, so he will undoubtedly have restrictions on him. Luis Castillo and Anthony Kay remain rotation options as well, but not ones that feel ideal to enter the season.

May is a nice addition to that group, but ideally fits into the middle of that rotation, ahead of those others mentioned and below Burke plus one more established arm.

The White Sox have been reported to be in on most of the non-Skubal top pitchers available and figure to remain in those conversations even after signing May. It will be interesting to see how much Chicago will spend though, especially with over $40 million committed to Castillo and Andrew Benintendi.

Beyond the free agent market, there could be names available for trade, but that would require the Sox seriously dipping into a fairly thin farm system.

Pitching depth can never be overdone, and the surplus of young arms waiting in the wings should not deter the White Sox from getting a frontline arm to further anchor this rotation.

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.