Most Notable Prospects Left Unprotected From the Rule 5 Draft

The Rule 5 Draft is unlikely to take place this year due to the looming lockout, which led to some interesting prospects going unprotected.

WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA - MARCH 19, 2026: Karson Milbrandt #83 of the Miami Marlins throws a pitch during the second inning of a spring training Spring Breakout game against the Houston Astros at CACTI Park of the Palm Beaches on March 19, 2026 in West Palm Beach, Florida. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images)

Last week at the GM Meetings, President of Baseball Operations David Stearns was asked how the looming lockout would impact the Mets offseason, and his answer was far from candid. He described things as “business as usual”, even though everyone knows it is anything but.

We are less than two weeks away from baseball going into a scheduled hibernation, with the expiration of the CBA on December 1st acting as a free agent deadline. All the madness will ensue whenever agents and executives alike finish their Thanksgiving meals.

That free agent frenzy may be the first time we outwardly see teams changing their behavior, but last night’s deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft was the first sign that things are not business as usual this time of year.

The last time we had a lockout the Winter Meetings were cancelled, and when the two sides would eventually come to terms on a new CBA, the Rule 5 Draft was skipped rather than rescheduled.

Ad – content continues below

If you followed along with what Stearns, and other GMs did last night, it would be pretty clear that there is some strategy behind how some teams are approaching this year’s Rule 5. And that strategy is to assume it’s not happening.

Why is it Worth it to Gamble Top Prospects on an Assumption?

The Mets are the perfect example for how teams are trying to take advantage of a year without a Rule 5 Draft.

If things were business as usual as Stearns described, the Mets probably would have protected more prospects than just Jefferson Rojas. Instead, they chose to just protect their very top guy, and rolled the dice on the rest of the system staying in tact because there is likely going to be no draft.

As you will read once we get into the top candidates below, the Mets have a pair of starting pitching prospects who would have gotten protected in a normal year. Prospects who are close enough to the big leagues, and are too valuable to the Mets starting pitching depth to allow them to be selected in a Rule 5 Draft.

Instead, the Mets now get to snake them through the offseason without adding them to the 40-man roster, which is great for roster flexibility both short and long-term.

In the short-term the team gets utilize the extra roster spots. Another wrinkle is that they have added benefit of being able to stay in contact with the prospects, as any player on the 40-man roster will have to cease contact with the big league club on December 2nd. The long-term impact is more significant however.

Once a player is added to the 40-man roster, they can only play in the minor leagues after being optioned. Teams get three option years with each given player, and front offices value those years tremendously.

If they can avoid adding a player to the roster, they get the chance to preserve all of their options, which can prove to be massive for a team in the long run. With the incentive clearly laid out, now is the perfect time to dive into some of the most surprising roster decisions at yesterday’s Rule 5 deadline.

Ad – content continues below

10 Notable MLB Prospects Left Unprotected

Creed Willems, Baltimore Orioles

  • Age: 23
  • Position: Catcher
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 111 G, 453 PA, .254/.347/.414, 21 HR, 11% BB%, 21.6% K%, 106 wRC+

The first notable absence from the Rule-5 protection deadline on Tuesday was Orioles catcher Creed Willems, who had put together a solid 2026 campaign. After hitting a career-high 21 homers between two levels, Willems finished the season in Triple-A, where he posted a 102 wRC+ across 111 games.

Willems also possesses intriguing exit velocity numbers, but will need to hone in on his swing decisions to truly maximize his profile. If a team is able to fine-tune these things, he could be a regular fixture on a big-league roster in 2027.

While his bat is far from top-100 caliber, he closely matches the mold of players that typically get protected in the Rule-5 Draft. For this reason, it was surprising to see him not be protected, especially considering that the Orioles were one of the more active teams on Tuesday. They added seven prospects to their 40-man roster in total, which was among the most in the league.

Blake Wehunt, Boston Red Sox

  • Age: 26
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 AA Stats: 13 GS, 53.2 IP, 3.52 ERA, 3.62 FIP, 12.07 K/9, 2.68 BB/9
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 10 GS, 46.2 IP, 3.47 ERA, 4.92 FIP, 6.17 K/9, 3.86 BB/9

In previous seasons, arms that are close to the big leagues and boast solid raw stuff are quite attractive to teams picking in the Rule-5 Draft. Due to this tendency, many people around the industry expected that right-handed pitcher Blake Wehunt might be protected by the Boston Red Sox on Tuesday.

Wehunt was the definition of an innings eater this season. Across 23 starts between two levels, he notched a 3.50 ERA with 104 strikeouts in 100.1 innings, occasionally showing flashes of being a solid rotation option at the next level. While the underlying data is a bit underwhelming, he excels at filling up the strike zone with good extension, which could help his raw stuff play better than expected at the next level.

While Wehunt was inevitably left off the Red Sox’s 40-man roster, he could be an arm worth taking a chance on for many teams around the league.

Jake Gelof, Los Angeles Dodgers

  • Age: 24
  • Position: 3B/2B/1B
  • 2026 AA Stats: 124 G, 522 PA, .271/.385/.565, 34 HR, 16.1% BB%, 27.0% K%, 140 wRC+

Over the past few seasons, the Los Angeles Dodgers have slowly built up one of the best player development pipelines in baseball, which has resulted in a tremendous farm system year-over-year.

While bigger-name prospects like Josue De Paula got most of the recognition this season, they quietly had multiple lethal power threats emerge in the system, and among them was infielder Jake Gelof.

Ad – content continues below

Aside from his eye-popping stat line that includes 34 homers and a 140 wRC+, Gelof’s underlying data points to him being a very solid power threat at the next level. He posted an impressive average exit velocity of 91.7 MPH this season, and when paired with his 40% air-pull rate, it builds confidence in his ability to slug in the big leagues.

Of course, like most power-over-hit prospects, there are some contact concerns in his profile. Gelof posted a contact rate of 71% this season, which could be a cause for concern in his future. However, this type of profile could be worth taking a chance on during the Rule-5 Draft.

Karson Milbrandt, Miami Marlins

  • Age: 22
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 AA Stats: 9 GS, 47 IP, 1.34 ERA, 2.83 FIP, 13.40 K/9, 3.26 BB/9
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 16 G, 15 GS, 64.1 IP, 8.39 ERA, 7.05 FIP, 8.67 K/9, 7.27 BB/9

Of all the prospects left unprotected from the Rule-5 Draft on Tuesday, arguably the most surprising name was Marlins right-hander Karson Milbrandt. He was the only Rule-5-eligible member of our top 100 who wasn’t added to the 40-man roster, which made this a very puzzling decision by the club.

Milbrandt kicked off the 2026 season with a tremendous nine-start stretch in Double-A, where he posted a 1.34 ERA and began to cement himself as a consensus top-100 prospect.

However, once he was promoted to Triple-A, Milbrandt ran into serious trouble. He lost his control and was hit quite hard over 64.1 innings, throwing a wrench in an otherwise positive 2026 season.

While the exact cause of his sudden struggles is still unknown, it’s been speculated that his struggles could be attributed to the inconsistency of the baseballs across the minor leagues. If he can get back on track, he would be a worthwhile risk for a team to take during the Rule-5 Draft.

Brayden Taylor, Miami Marlins

  • Age: 24
  • Position: 2B/3B/SS
  • 2026 AA Stats: 88 G, 380 PA, .284/.384/.513, 17 HR, 13.4% BB%, 22.9% K%, 136 wRC+
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 33 G, 129 PA, .194/.372/.418, 4 HR, 21.7% BB%, 24.8% K%, 116 wRC+

The Marlins continued their puzzling Rule-5 decisions by leaving former first-round pick Brayden Taylor unprotected from the Rule-5 Draft, marking yet another stunning decision by the club.

Aside from his prospect pedigree and solid 2026 season, Taylor was the headliner of the Liam Hicks deal back in August, which made this move even more peculiar.

Ad – content continues below

After a disappointing 2025 season that saw Taylor finish with a wRC+ below 140 for the first time in his professional career, he got back on track in 2026. He posted a 131 wRC+ with a career-high 21 homers despite dealing with the whirlwind of being traded and earning a Triple-A promotion.

With this in mind, it came as a surprise to see Taylor left off the Marlins’ 40-man roster. Taylor held his own in Triple-A to finish the season, notching a wRC+ of 116 through 33 games and inspiring confidence in his big-league future.

Due to this stint, there is a belief that Taylor could start in the big leagues sooner rather than later, which could make him a fascinating name to watch during the Rule-5 Draft.

Brock Wilken, Milwaukee Brewers

  • Age: 24
  • Position: 1B/3B
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 130 G, 543 PA, .191/.319/.365, 17 HR, 14.9% BB%, 28% K%, 85 wRC+

Ever since his days at Wake Forest prior to professional baseball, Brewers infielder Brock Wilken has been hailed as having electric, game-altering power. It was this power that led to his selection 18th overall in the 2023 MLB Draft, but his results at the professional level haven’t been ideal to this point.

Despite his pedigree as a former first-rounder, Wilken’s hit tool has been spotty to this point. He struggled to make the transition to Triple-A during the 2026 season, as he saw his strikeout rate finish at 28% while his wRC+ fell below 100 for the first time in his young career.

While his bat could experience a resurgence in the future, the Brewers made the calculated decision to leave him exposed ahead of the Rule-5 Draft. It seems unlikely that he will be selected, but many teams around the league may still take a chance on his status and power potential.

Gary Gill Hill, New York Mets

  • Age: 22
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 AA Stats (TBR): 15 GS, 81.1 IP, 4.43 ERA, 4.39 FIP, 6.75 K/9, 1.55 BB/9
  • 2026 AA Stats (NYM): 5 GS, 26.1 IP, 3.76 ERA, 3.52 FIP, 9.57 K/9, 1.71 BB/9

Acquired by the New York Mets at the trade deadline in the Freddy Peralta trade, Gary Gill Hill was likely dealt by the Rays because he was Rule 5 Draft eligible and they are in a perpetual 40-man roster crunch.

In a normal year, Gill Hill is the type of arm teams would really struggle to push through a Rule 5 Draft. This is simply because he throws so many strikes. Few pitchers live in the zone as much as Gary Gill Hill, and he does it while being able to pump fastballs at 95 MPH.

Ad – content continues below

The ceiling may not be the highest for Gill Hill, but he is the type of depth arm that teams feel they could take as a Rule 5 pick and he can at the very least provide some innings for you as a back-end starter or in a long-man role.

Then again, Gill Hill saw a big uptick in strikeouts once he got to the Mets, so maybe there is room for him to develop into something more. The Mets must be expecting no Rule 5 Draft, because otherwise there is a good chance that Gill Hill’s time in the Mets organization could be short-lived.

Jack Wenninger, New York Mets

  • Age: 24
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 Triple-A Stats: 26 G, 22 GS, 115 IP, 4.54 ERA, 5.16 FIP, 9.63 K/9, 5.32 BB/9

There was a point early last year where Jack Wenninger found himself on our top 100. A rough season in Triple-A dropped him off that list, but this is still a starting pitcher who is close to the big leagues and has flashed a deep enough arsenal to stick in the rotation at the next level.

Wenninger is only a year removed from a breakout season that saw him pitch to a 2.92 ERA across 135 2/3 innings pitched in Double-A. Wenninger pitched some big games down the stretch that year, helping lead the Binghamton Rumble Ponies to an Eastern League title.

The 24-year-old struck out 26.4% of the batters that he faced, while only walking 7.6%. The strikeout rate didn’t drop too much in Triple-A, but his walk rate spiked over 13%. Between issuing more free passes, and giving up more home runs, Wenninger’s season turned into a real slog in 2026.

Still, there is enough hope for a bounce back, and Wenninger’s proximity to the big leagues would make him an interesting candidate to be selected in the Rule 5 Draft.

Joe Whitman, San Francisco Giants

  • Age: 25
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 AA Stats: 10 GS, 50.1 IP, 3.22 ERA, 2.37 FIP, 11.62 K/9, 2.32 BB/9
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 22 G, 14 GS, 84.1 IP, 3.74 ERA, 4.73 FIP, 7.36 K/9, 2.45 BB/9

Recently, the San Francisco Giants have quietly been building one of the strongest farm systems in the league. With their farm shaping up to be a powerhouse, tough decisions have to be made along the way. On Tuesday, the Giants decided to leave Joe Whitman off their 40-man roster, which was quite shocking.

At times, Whitman has looked like he could be a very good major league starting pitcher. However, the issue is his consistency and the fact that he lacks truly dominant stuff on the mound.

Ad – content continues below

Despite finishing with a 3.54 ERA between two levels this season, hitters made a lot of hard contact against his offerings, which could eventually translate to his inconsistent results continuing once he reaches the big leagues.

While Whitman’s underlying data raises concerns for his future, he did handle Triple-A well enough that a team may be willing to give him a shot during the Rule-5 Draft. He matches the mold of prospects who are usually taken during this process, which is another signal that he could be on the move as a result of this decision.

Gage Stanifer, Toronto Blue Jays

  • Age: 23
  • Position: Starting Pitcher
  • 2026 AA Stats: 28 G, 19 GS, 97 IP, 4.82 ERA, 4.87 FIP, 12.34 K/9, 5.94 BB/9
  • 2026 AAA Stats: 3 G, 3.2 IP, 4.91 ERA, 1.30 FIP, 17.18 K/9, 4.91 BB/9

The Toronto Blue Jays farm system has experienced its share of roster crunches, leading to difficult choices ahead of the Rule-5 protection deadline. Among the most notable omissions was right-hander Gage Stanifer, whose disappointing 2026 campaign ultimately left him exposed to the rest of the league.

After putting together a sharp 2025 season where Stanifer generated some buzz as a potential top-100 prospect, 2026 ended up being a different story for the 23-year-old. Through 100.2 innings between two levels, his ERA spiked to 4.83, which was a little under two full points higher than his mark last season.

While Stanifer’s numbers might cause some teams to shy away from selecting him, he carries a well-rounded arsenal, and he generates a lot of strikeouts. He’s the type of arm that might be a control tweak away from being a successful big leaguer, and for that reason, he may be selected during the Rule 5 Draft.

Become a Member of Just Baseball

Subscribe and upgrade to go ad-free!

* Save 25% by subscribing annually.